Some great portable MIDI controllers are: The more keys the keyboard has, the more desk space it will occupy. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Share. You cannot paste images directly. He lives in San Diego and freelances as a producer and part-time DJ. Let's start with the keyboard. MIDINaton is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. You can also choose between two sound banks. Everything about this unit screams quality. So working with other manfuacturers, including Yamaha, Korg, etc., Kakehashi came up with a universal specification for connecting electronic instruments together. I searched all kinds of things here, but couldn't find what I need. A keyboard that works with Ableton or Pro Tools is also going to work with Logic Pro X. Instead of using the mouse and adding/removing notes, you can play them via your keyboard and instantly hear what you want to play. This is the reason why top pad controllers support Ableton out of the box. That's just the tip of the iceberg depending on the keyboard, you can change everything from the track EQ to the depth, bend, volume, etc. Whats the Absolute Best Yamaha Keyboard and Digital Piano in 2022? You can buy the Nanonkey2 in three variants, depending on your needs: Which variant you buy and how you use it will vary a lot. Clear editor. olavsu1, 14 hours ago After a week of trying just about everything, I'm afraid I'm giving up for now. Here Logic seems to get confused often and It's not trustworthy. First let's open up Logic's Controller Assignments window (shift + alt + K, or Logic Pro X > Control Surfaces >..). Cristianp, Even in the session that's giving me a problem, if you go back to the tracks that originally did not work, the problem re-occurs! If youre used to $500 guitars and $1,000 digital pianos, youll be pleased to know that you can buy very competent MIDI controllers for Logic Pro X for under $200. You don't get aftertouch but you do get three touch sensitivity settings. in Logic Pro, Copyright 2022 Logic Pro Help in Logic Pro, By If you want to play music using this synth, you need to connect it to a keyboard. What kind, and how many control options you need will depend entirely on your production style. Plus, you get dedicated DAW controls and a tiny LCD screen to give you track and MIDI information. Im quite proficient with Logic but am new to the environment. Some of the best MIDI controllers plug effortlessly into Logic Pro X, allowing you instant control over your DAW. Great for people who like a more intuitive approach to their music production. Can you provide a screenshot of your tracks area with the inspector visible? If I have say Modern Strings on one track, and piano on the other - no problemo. They're not as large and sensitive as Akai's APC controllers but they get the job done. Compared to the original MK1, the APC40 MK2 is sleekier and stealthier. Dupont, 1 hour ago Buy synth-action keyboards if you want a functional MIDI controller and dont have much piano playing experience. But portability comes with its own compromise smaller keys. Are the tracks you are using Software Instrument tracks or aux tracks? Configure Each Controller Keyboard's MIDI Channel Select a MIDI channel for each controller, and connect to each controller's manual to observe how to change the MIDI channel they transfer on. Integrations wont be a problem but will require more effort. You can post now and register later. July 27, 2014 in Logic Pro. Powered by Invision Community. Instead, the weight of the keys depending on the octave you're in affects how quickly they spring back up. When I set up 2 controllers in this way (using ch1 and ch2 as suggested) I'm getting a strange behaviour (v10.4). By Iain, July 19, 2009 in Logic Pro. I'm on Logic 10.0.7. The Roland A-500PRO also boasts 8 faders, 8+1 knobs, 8 dynamic pads, and an array of buttons. And 88-key keyboards are typically over 4 wide. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account. Have you seen this thread and followed David's instructions? Your best option is to spring for semi-weighted keys. Switching between VSTs, especially in live settings, is never easier. Therefore I'm unable to find which MIDI channel it's on. The Nektar Impact LX49+ (compare price Sweetwater, Guitar Center, Amazon) isn't the best MIDI keyboard controller on the market. But there was a problem: all these devices used differernt proprietory connections sucha s CV/gate. The companys MPC controllers revolutionized music production in the late 80s and 90s. The Nanokey won't replace a full-fledged MIDI controller for Logic Pro. You would not normally need to work in AMS. I cant create an Audio or MIDI channel. Apart from the pads, you also get 8 programmable knobs. Behringer X-Touch Compact Universal USB Midi Controller Faders that Dance with Your Music Control More A Symphony of Lights A Tale of Two MIDIs Connect, Control, Expand Check Latest Price Product Details I'm new to this forum I'm quite proficient with Logic but am new to 'the environment'. MIDI controllers arent very expensive as far as musical instruments go. Both pad and keyboard controllers usually have additional control options such as dials, faders, etc. It gives you access to four octaves of range. Also another problem I have is that when multiple channels are selected, I only want my MIDI controllers to play their specific instruments. About your reviewer In Logic Pro X, select File > Project Settings > Recording, and in the MIDI section, choose Auto demix by channel when multitrack recording. Unless you have extensive piano playing experience, I would recommend that you stick to hybrid controllers. tsengil, Sunday at 05:43 PM Much of the insight comes from experience using different keyboards and pads and controllers over time. In fact, I'm tempted to dub this the best MPC for Logic Pro X as well unless you truly need a dedicated MPC. As one of the best DAWs around, Logic Pro X enjoys widespread compatibility with most hardware. Pasted as rich text. One of my favorite features and a rarity among MIDI controllers is the semi-weighted keybed. So before you spring for a larger keyboard, measure out your desk. Powered by Invision Community, http://logicprohelp.com/viewtopic.php?t=32201. The Nanokey2 is one of the smallest MIDI controllers on the market. (CMD+OPT+N) and specified 1 in the Number of tracks, then repeated again. That's not all. Logic Pro 10.6.2. The keyboard is synth-action and velocity sensitive. Hey guys, Thanks for taking the time to read and potentially help. It can sound like a guitar, a piano chord, an electronic synth, a ukulele, etc. Check out our best Logic Pro X content to build out your studio including headphones, audio interfaces, and control surfaces selected specifically for Logic Pro X: Our best control surfaces for Logic Pro X, A close look at the best audio interfaces for Logic, Our top-rated studio headphones for Logic Pro X, We use rigorous research, reviews, and real-world performance when recommending products. The controller must be a commercially available production model, not an obscure custom brand. But when recording, the controller on the current track activates the software instruments on both tracks. Display as a link instead, This makes the entire music production process far more intuitive and natural. Pad controllers are great for launching clips and creating spontaneous compositions. in Logic Pro, By If you have a smaller desk, it could completely ruin your setup. You can post now and register later. Midi Nation is supported by our great readers. A word about integrations with Logic Pro X. Logic Pro X Multiple plugin instance MIDI controller issues. But if I have any patch that has the same articulations as Modern strings on the second track then it follows the articulations. You cant use it to launch clips the same way you can use Abletons session view. But amazingly, any new sessions are now working just fine. With these caveats out of the way, lets look at my top picks for the best MIDI controllers for Logic Pro X: Its a rare best-of list that doesnt have the ever-popular Akai MPK249 (compare price Sweetwater, Guitar Center, Amazon) right at the very top. Just tested it here in case there was a new bug or something but no, it works fine: MIDI channel 1 data (coming in via any port) goes to the track that has the MIDI channel 1 set in the track inspector, MIDI channel 2 data (coming in via any port) goes to the track that has MIDI channel 2 set in its inspector, etc. Click this link to your signature and add your system information: Logic version and sub-version (e.g. By Powered by Invision Community, Have you tried adjusting the MIDI channel in the Track Inspector to a specific channel (instead of. And the faders are plasticky. Your previous content has been restored. Clear editor. You don't really need a MIDI keyboard to make music. By There is no audio information yet that has to be supplied by the other device. Oxygen 49 where I arbitrarily set channel 2 on the hardware. I am curious if someone can confirm that they use an Oxygen 49 controller with another controller successfully, (with the same configuration as in my signature) and/or a TD-11 with another controller, because the only thing I can think of is something with one of those controllers and somehow confusing Logic with the Port, although it doesn't really explain why the channels do come in OK (as shown in the PDF in the previous post). Start new topic. And then there are times when you'd rather have something tiny that can squirrel away in a corner of your desk. I appreciate everyone's help, this is such a great forum. If so which one? It will become hidden in your post, but will still be visible via the comment's permalink. Logic Pro ; Multiple midi controllers Multiple midi controllers. It also boasts some great software features. The key action will disappoint serious piano players. Julia Mosley, October 4 Which instruments (plugins or hardware) are involved? In a transition period of evolving my set up hugely so facing all these teething problems. Related Topics Logic Pro Apple Inc. Information & communications technology Consumer electronics Business, Economics, and Finance Technology Electronics industry Consumer discretionary sector Business Pasted as rich text. On that screen I can adjust the MIDI channel it transmits on. But for a beginner or someone looking for their first device, this is one of the best MIDI controllers for Logic Pro X on the market. Key quality (for keyboard controllers), and pad quality (for pad controllers), 24 assignable Q-Link controllers include knobs, faders, and switches (8 of each), MPC Note Repeat, MPC Swing, and arpeggiator for advanced rhythmic and melodic manipulation, Pitch bend, modulation, and octave controls for expressive recording and performing, Software instruments automatically mapped to controls, 4-way thumbstick for dynamic pitch and modulation control, 8 backlit velocity-sensitive MPC-style pads, Dedicated Octave Up and Octave Down buttons, Pads are RGB backlit for color coded clips, Complete DAW control without using keyboard/mouse, Assignable A/B crossfader for mixing on the fly, Velocity-sensitive 49 keys with channel after touch, 45 assignable controls: knobs, sliders, buttons, transport and more, 8 Dynamic Pads for finger drumming and MIDI triggering, Configuration options: 25 keys, 8 faders, or 16 pads, 25-key variant has sustain button for piano parts. You can read more about our, Most beginners and intermediate players should aim for a budget between $100-$200. The faders are also auto-assigned to the mixer by hitting the mixer' button. Pad controllers, which have large drum pads, faders, knobs and buttons. The faders also don't have the mechanical heft of the keys. For instance, you might have a MOOG synth. Without a MIDI keyboard, you have to open the DAW, drag the mouse over to the pitch/octave parameter, then drag it up/down. This is really frustrating. Youll get a good mix of build-quality, key-quality, and controls. The 49-key version of Roland's mid-range controller, the A-500Pro (compare price Amazon, Guitar Center) is no different. Change the LCD display mode in Logic Pro; Monitor and reset MIDI events; Use the cycle area; Use the Chase Events function; Use Apple Remote to control Logic Pro; Use Logic Remote to control Logic Pro projects; Set project properties. The APC40 integrates right out of the box with Ableton, but to get it work with Logic, youll have to switch things around in smart controls (heres a guide). As a few days off gave me a few new ideas to try. olavsu1, 14 hours ago The keys are mini in keeping with the portability theme. Thanks to anyone who can help me solve this probably super simple issue. The end result is a astonishingly well-built and capable controller at a price tag that's affordable for virtually every musician. Ill look at the differences between pad and keyboard controllers later. Akai Pro MPD 218 16 Backlit MPC Pads 6 endless rotary knobs 3 banks for pads and knobs 16 user-configurable presets MPC note-repeat and full-level features The Low Down If you have even a few months of piano playing experience, youll enjoy semi-weighted keyboards far more. I'm wondering if anyone else has experienced difficulty setting up multiple midi controllers. There is no sessions view like in Ableton, which limits what you can do with pad controllers. The MPK Mini MK2 is VIP3.0 compatible, which really opens up live performance options. Logic 10.0.7), OS X version and sub-version (e.g. MIDI controllers come in basically two broad variants: pad controllers or keyboard controllers. Not a killer feature but useful (and missing from several competitors in this range). If multiple devices are sending on MIDI channel 1, they will all go to the track with that MIDI channel assignment. Both tracks are record-enabled and "Auto-demix by channel if multirack recording" is checked of course. Note that if I have TWO HARDWARE devices all is OK, the problem is triggering SOFTWARE plug ins. I had first-hand experience of 13 of these controllers. If the controller specifically says that it supports a specific DAW, it might be a good idea to pick something else. Switch over to the freshly created tracks, and everything's perfect. Hey guys, I'm trying to hook up an M-Audio Oxygen 49 MIDI keyboard via USB + Roland S88 MIDI into M-Audio ProjectMix via FireWire onto Logic Pro 9; I want to have each keyboard play separate instruments without layering them. Well start with a quick overview of my review methodology before sharing my list of the top ten picks. Given the price, you can even buy all three and change them around based on what you need at the moment. When youre owned by the biggest company in the world, you can bet that manufacturers and software developers alike will bend over backwards to supporft you. Here is a Logic forum, not (oxygen, roland). 61-key keyboards come in around 3.5 to 4 in width. My recommendation: get a MIDI controller with at least 8 pads, and at least 8+8 faders/knobs combo. You can record only what is routed to the Sequencer Input, so if your intention is to record, I wouldn't mess with the default cabling in the Environment. MIDI makes it possible for the two devices to talk to each other. For a more detailed explanation of Akai MPK and our impressions, check out the review below: 49 full-sized keys, 9 faders, 8 backlit pads, 8 knobs, 9 buttons, DAW controls, a LCD information screen, and a price tag that's surprisingly affordable. Hybrid controllers, which have both traditional piano keys and a set of drum pads, faders, and knobs. Thanks for the response about the MPK. Restore formatting, in Logic Pro, By Ableton recognizes each of these separately and allows me to assign different MIDI controllers as inputs to individual soft synth patches How do I assign separate MIDI controllers as inputs to individual synths on Logic Pro 9 without having the sounds stack on top of each other? MIDI channel, patches selection, external MIDI gear, etc could all be dealt with from within Logic. This not only feels better, but also has a non-slippery surface great when you're sweating after a long jamming session. [Note: I even tried using the multi-timbral instrument Trillian, arbitrarily setting channel to 6 of the Auxiliary channel.